←back to thread

376 points undefined1 | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.591s | source
Show context
danielscrubs ◴[] No.22975715[source]
Can someone explain to me why affirmative action is necessary? Why not just send in your GPA and let a computer check which school you can go to based on your preference? Why resort to low-key racism?

Low-income junior high-schools of course needs more money from the government than the high-income schools to combat equality issues. Because let's face it, it's the low-income people that struggle and always will, money IS power.

replies(3): >>22975744 #>>22975898 #>>22975936 #
balls187 ◴[] No.22975898[source]
> Why not just send in your GPA and let a computer check which school you can go to based on your preference? Why resort to low-key racism?

College admissions were based that way. And it disproportionately benefited white students, and affirmative action policies were implemented to combat that.

Think of Affirmative Action similar to weighted GPA's.

College Admissions attempted to take a population and normalize them to a pair of datapoints (GPA/SAT/ACT). Affirmative action policies attempted to weigh lower scores higher, factoring in historical biases.

A (white) friend explained it like this: Think of playing a game of monopoly and if you're white you start with 2x the money, and given 1/4 of the properties on the board. If you're black, you start with 1/2 the money, and the all prices are doubled. How likely is it for a black person to win?

replies(2): >>22976035 #>>22976233 #
starpilot ◴[] No.22976035[source]
Even controlled for income, achievement disparities persist between races. Also imagine: everytime you make a bad play, you go to jail, while the white player does not. Even as children, black kids receive harsher punishments (full on suspensions) than white kids (time-outs) for similar infractions. Imagine your whole life being told that you're bad and disruptive. You might start to internalize and normalize that message, and not try very hard as a result.
replies(1): >>22977551 #
1. luckylion ◴[] No.22977551[source]
> Imagine your whole life being told that you're bad and disruptive.

Sounds like you're talking about "the male experience".

It's interesting that it's the situation of black men that is generalized as "that's what it's like for black people".

replies(1): >>22987994 #
2. bsanr2 ◴[] No.22987994[source]
No, black girls are also much more likely than white girls to be disciplined, often harshly and physically, and often by people who are not their family. "School resource officer body slams female black student" is practically a YouTube genre unto itself.