←back to thread

2525 points hownottowrite | 4 comments | | HN request time: 0.432s | source
1. beart ◴[] No.21191233[source]
As I recall, Blizzard decided to remove skeletons and some other things from World of Warcraft years ago in order to enter the Chinese market.
replies(3): >>21191600 #>>21193937 #>>21194423 #
2. Fnoord ◴[] No.21191600[source]
Not at all the same though. If I release software specifically for a national market, I adapt to the local law of that nation. In this case, the software is WoW, and the country is China. It could have been Wolfenstein and the country being Germany. It could have been a nipple in a game, and the country being USA. We don't notice such.

However, in this case, we're at an Asian (not Chinese) esports event where one should be free to express their opinion. It is not as if we don't see skeleton cosplay on esport events being banned, or that Germany demands Wolfenstein esports events (?) don't contain blood and Nazi paraphernalia. It is not as if the USA complains about a nipple on TwitchCon in Amsterdam. This is about a country applying censorship beyond their jurisdiction.

3. papreclip ◴[] No.21193937[source]
Nothing wrong with that. You might laugh at skeletons being where they choose to draw the line, but we have rules as well about what can happen in a video game. There are no kids in Grand Theft Auto for a reason.

Also, Blizzard only removed them from the game in china

What would be more disturbing is if they had to rewrite some orc-politics story so it wouldn't offend chinese sensibilities, and US consumers got the rewritten version as well.

The movie Red Dawn(2012) was a remake of a 1984 action film where a communist army invades the US. They updated the invader from the USSR to China, come to "repossess" the US after we defaulted on national debt. This offended the chinese, so the producers had to spend $1M editing every reference to china in the film and making it a North Korean invasion instead. This was the version US consumers were sold.

4. hannasanarion ◴[] No.21194423[source]
Removing/changing artistic depictions because they have unintended meaning in a different cultural context is one thing.

Cutting LGBT characters and banning people who criticize the regime is entirely different.