←back to thread

1456 points pulisse | 3 comments | | HN request time: 1.763s | source
Show context
chrischen ◴[] No.21185420[source]
China executes an official Taiwan belongs to China stance to save face, as communist bureaucracies love to do.

In practice, their official policy lets Taiwan exist as an independently governed region more than the US even allows Hawaii or Cuba to be independent. Even Canada has more of a attachment to the US and its laws than Taiwan does.

This is probably a fact lost on most foreigners unaware of the situation.

If China really wanted to assimilate Taiwan they would not have such deeply connected bilateral trade, cross-border tourism, or give access to their market by Taiwanese companies like Foxconn, HTC, Asus, and hundreds more.

China does impose tourism restrictions to pressure Taiwan, but if they really wanted to crush Taiwan they can easily do so without raising so much as a hand gun.

The funny thing is armchair Chinese nationalists (people on the other side of the planet reading hacker news) are more up in arms about this than actual Taiwanese people because the de-jure stance has always been like this, and the de-facto independence of Taiwan has been pretty stable.

replies(2): >>21186438 #>>21187963 #
philliphaydon ◴[] No.21186438[source]
People in Taiwan can freely travel to China. But people in China can only travel to Taiwan via a tour group. So there’s no pressure to taiwan on tourism...
replies(1): >>21187532 #
chrischen ◴[] No.21187532[source]
They often restrict tourism from Mainland China as leverage, as Taiwan receives a lot of tourism revenue from China.
replies(1): >>21188083 #
1. philliphaydon ◴[] No.21188083[source]
The restriction of not allowing mainland into Taiwan is controlled by Taiwan. Not by China... Taiwan is the one that put the policy in place that China can only visit Taiwan via a tour group only.
replies(1): >>21188243 #
2. chrischen ◴[] No.21188243[source]
Here you go: https://www.dw.com/en/taiwan-reduces-reliance-on-mainland-ch...

"Beijing's attempt to punish Taiwan by throttling tourism from the mainland hasn't made much impact. Taiwan set a new tourism record last year by successfully courting visitors from the rest of Asia."

Yes Taiwan has the sovereignty to do that, but China also has exit restrictions (USA does not have exit restrictions, which I assume is why you may be unfamiliar with this concept).

replies(1): >>21188585 #
3. philliphaydon ◴[] No.21188585[source]
Ah ok. I haven’t been to China. I’m in taiwan right now. People here really don’t like mainland China tourists and always complain.