←back to thread

1456 points pulisse | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.444s | source
Show context
tibbon ◴[] No.21184395[source]
What's it take for an engineer in the US to actually do something like this?

If my boss/product manager wanted me to do something like this, I'd be calling them out for shitty politics, and telling them they need to find a new engineer because I'd quit immediately - and likely incite others to come with me.

Maybe I have a higher sense of morality than others, but I'm no shill for China's power over Taiwan. I can use my entitlement/privilege as an engineer to say "fuck off" to anyone who wants me to do things I find immoral. Furthering the needs of a power hungry regime looking to assert dominance over others? Nope. I spend all my day working to further democracy and freedom, not to enable free thought and self-determination to be squashed.

Whoever coded this change and approved this PR, shame on you.

replies(33): >>21184428 #>>21184431 #>>21184492 #>>21184500 #>>21184510 #>>21184524 #>>21184534 #>>21184575 #>>21184603 #>>21184639 #>>21184651 #>>21184655 #>>21184657 #>>21184760 #>>21184784 #>>21184802 #>>21184840 #>>21184903 #>>21184916 #>>21185103 #>>21185143 #>>21185144 #>>21185165 #>>21185252 #>>21185274 #>>21185287 #>>21185423 #>>21185551 #>>21185554 #>>21185560 #>>21185770 #>>21185850 #>>21185902 #
vl ◴[] No.21185274[source]
Each truly international product has hundreds, if not thousands policies like this codified. How to render border between India and Pakistan, Russia and Ukraine, what words to exclude from dictionaries and suspend in auto-suggest, etc.

For engineer it’s just another rule, they get update like “locale X passed the law to do Y, update software to comply”. It’s not their job to do legal or ethical evaluations, and it’s unreasonable to expect it from them.

If you think it’s obvious, and any engineer should be well-equipped to do so, there is a story from inside the Big G. When Google employees had a protest-du-jour about Google planning to implement restricted version of search in China, it turned out that many Google employees of Chinese descent actually supported implemented restricted search in China arguing that restricted search is better than no search. Now, if you were an internatialization engineer working on restricting features, how would you evaluate claims of both groups and is it your responsibility to do so?

replies(1): >>21185364 #
1. PowerfulWizard ◴[] No.21185364[source]
As the old saying goes, you don't create a HideTaiwan() function, you create a HideCountry() function and require Taiwan to be provided as a parameter.