←back to thread

171 points BrooklynRage | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.23s | source
Show context
baybal2 ◴[] No.21168516[source]
I protest, totally protest. Under no circumstances let people with dotcom webdev mentality run anything really serious in aeronautics.

I myself had a rather similar talk to what that the panelist had with Kitty Hawk people with a very well moneyed, but also very naive CEO of a drone delivery startup. Some sarcasm added, but it went along these lines:

Me: your best bet is to make a helicopter. Men much brighter than you were banging their heads against the wall non-stop for 60 years trying to solve this exact problem.

Startup CEO: But I hired most brilliant engineers from Amazon and Waymo for that. I'm paying them near 200k each.

Me: If this, this, and this thing breaks, your drone drops dead upon an urban area. And if you get into negative gees over ridgelines, your motor don't have enough torque to keep COM behind the centre of aerodynamic forces to prevent inversion. You can't change the law of gravity.

And he was like "can't we really do anything about that, can't we?" These people are so used to the culture of "easy solutions" that it's scary.

A convertoplane this big will be extremely unstable in wind gusts

replies(4): >>21168534 #>>21168543 #>>21168546 #>>21168708 #
pubby ◴[] No.21168546[source]
I haven't been following the project. How do you know they have webdev mentality?
replies(1): >>21168598 #
1. dmix ◴[] No.21168598[source]
The company's lead is Sebastian Thurn who has been working on robotics, self driving cars, and AI since the early 1990s.

One of the most successful car makers in history from the early days of mass production of cars was run by an accountant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alfred_P._Sloan

The OP is spreading FUD.