←back to thread

1293 points rmason | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
socrates1998 ◴[] No.19323322[source]
Anecdotally, I work with teenagers and none of them have a Facebook pages. It's viewed as a place for old people and parents.

For me personally, it's almost impossible to deal with. Way too many political posts from my friends and family.

It's probably best use for me is local events and an occasional major event from a friend/family member.

Still, I find myself going there less and less.

From a small business standpoint, it's just not worth the time, effort and money to advertise there. It's much more effective to focus on getting referrals with my current clients.

I really wish there was a paid social media service that everyone used. I would gladly pay $5-$10 a month for something that didn't sell my data.

replies(15): >>19323410 #>>19323503 #>>19323591 #>>19323620 #>>19323626 #>>19323637 #>>19323716 #>>19323721 #>>19324033 #>>19324064 #>>19324090 #>>19324919 #>>19325055 #>>19326803 #>>19329622 #
AnimalMuppet ◴[] No.19323620[source]
> I would gladly pay $5-$10 a month for something that didn't sell my data.

Hmm. Facebook has something like 2 billion profiles. Of course, most of them wouldn't pay $5/month - say that only one percent would. 20 million profiles times $5/month = $100 million/month. It might be worth it for someone to try to build such a thing...

replies(3): >>19323701 #>>19323934 #>>19324118 #
davnicwil ◴[] No.19324118[source]
An anecdotal story about this - a couple of years ago I built a paid, ad-free privacy-focused social network, did several Show HNs for it and even here, in a community that seems quite receptive to the idea in principle, there was extremely low interest in it.

I got probably 50 sign-ups over a few Show HNs, no more than 4/5 upvotes and comments on the most well-received Show HN, and those who came in just posted one or two test posts, found obviously that nobody else was on there and left never to be seen again. Obviously none converted to a paid account (you could get 10 connections for free then afterwards pay $2/month).

Bootstrapping any social network, let alone a paid one, is hard. But I did try :-)

replies(2): >>19324826 #>>19325113 #
justaguyhere ◴[] No.19325113[source]
It is super hard to bootstrap, but sites like Facebook and Twitter already have hundreds of millions of users. Can't they run an experiment - something like "no ads/tracking for $5 (or whatever amount) per month" and see if there are any takers? If 20M sign up, that is 100M revenue per month.

Maybe they considered it and then rejected it as not viable?

replies(1): >>19325291 #
1. AnimalMuppet ◴[] No.19325291[source]
Or maybe they make more off of ads per month than they think any reasonable user would pay.