←back to thread

1293 points rmason | 8 comments | | HN request time: 0.971s | source | bottom
1. ryanianian ◴[] No.19323648[source]
I live in a somewhat large gated community that has a pretty active facebook group. The group is somewhat loosely moderated by the HOA (for better or worse) so in general people stay on-topic and neighborly. It's great for asking for recommended contractors, asking if somebody has a thing they can borrow, etc. This is one of the few things that keeps me on facebook.

Of course facebook is a terrible venue for this group - with its algorithmic feed, horrible search, and showing "notifications" when nothing of consequence has actually happened. If there were a more prevalent network I'm sure the group would move but there's really no other alternative that already has a critical mass of users and people aren't going to sign up for a new service unless everyone else in the neighborhood is already there.

replies(3): >>19323691 #>>19323983 #>>19324083 #
2. atwebb ◴[] No.19323691[source]
Nextdoor really needs to get it's act together on siloing neighborhood discussions, it's basically built for this.
replies(2): >>19323901 #>>19324247 #
3. echelon ◴[] No.19323901[source]
Nextdoor is terrible. I get push notified of every lost cat or dog. Or whenever the local grocery store is out of cabbage. Or "suspicious people" walking around. I can't find a way to get any value out of it.
replies(2): >>19324048 #>>19324113 #
4. romwell ◴[] No.19323983[source]
>If there were a more prevalent network I'm sure the group would move

I'm pretty sure there is one literally Nextdoor...

5. romwell ◴[] No.19324048{3}[source]
>Or "suspicious people"

The bane of Nextdoor. Every person within 100 yards is suspicious, especially if they have "Hair color: african" (I kid you not, this one is from my neighborhood Nextdoor).

6. ◴[] No.19324083[source]
7. ◴[] No.19324113{3}[source]
8. axaxs ◴[] No.19324247[source]
Nextdoor is awful. I think the idea was really good, but I've really just come to learn that by and large, my neighborhood is full of idiots. I guess the whole reason for social media is that we can choose who to be around, whereas we can't chose our neighbors. I only lasted about a month before the constant barrages of arguing over leash laws, petty snide comments, and self promoting 'handymen' drove me away.