←back to thread

1798 points jerryX | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
CalChris ◴[] No.18567228[source]
Regina Dugan is a former head of DARPA as well as ATAP. She has an impressive resume. Why would she do something like this? For a not particularly important patent, LED popup books? It seems bizarre.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regina_E._Dugan

replies(12): >>18567349 #>>18567354 #>>18567565 #>>18567779 #>>18567933 #>>18568015 #>>18568045 #>>18568363 #>>18568403 #>>18568873 #>>18569685 #>>18569787 #
ilaksh ◴[] No.18567933[source]
People don't get to the top by being ethical. They get to the top of the org chart by playing politics. Many of them are practically psychopaths.
replies(4): >>18567996 #>>18568054 #>>18568590 #>>18568842 #
speedplane ◴[] No.18568054[source]
The good news is that very few people are at the top. Most are in the middle, and it's entirely possible to be ethical and in a good middling position.
replies(2): >>18568244 #>>18568266 #
bitL ◴[] No.18568244[source]
How can you justify your work in the middle as ethical, if it directly supports a rotten apple at the top? Your life's work turned into a support system for a beast, wonderful!
replies(2): >>18569162 #>>18581705 #
1. speedplane ◴[] No.18581705[source]
I suppose it depends how you view the system and the rotten apple.

A properly functioning complex system should be able to tolerate a few bad apples, limiting the harm that they can cause. If you work in such a system and there are bad apples, you can justify the ethics of your work if there are checks and balances that limit the leader's ability to harm.

The obvious analogy is the current U.S. political system. It's quite possible to see the United States as generally striving for a more fair society, and generally good, and yet to be disgusted by Trump's cruelty and inept. The only way to square those two competing ideas is to acknowledge that even though Trump is a miserable rotten apple, he doesn't really have all the power. As bad as he is, he won't last forever, and the principals of the U.S. will long survive him.