←back to thread

1798 points jerryX | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.206s | source
Show context
paul7986 ◴[] No.18567672[source]
I met/had a similar experience with Google ATAP in 2013 (was Motorala ATAP then; Google recently bought them) though not for a job interview but to discuss working together to build our tech SpeakerBlast into the Moto X.

They asked if we ever thought about selling our technology to them before the meeting and at the meeting they baited us for how our tech worked saying we'd like to work with you tell us how it works. Once we did they left the room (Dugan's 2nd right hand man at the time and another) & 3 minutes later showed us the door saying the "race is on."

They have since been awarded patents for audio syncing across phones.

Many here will say that's just how Silicon Valley works.... takes advantage and stomps on the little guy innovators & their dreams. That's not professional and I met with many other companies like Samsung who acted with the utmost respect & professionalism towards us. Yet, Google whose motto is "Don't Be Evil," can't act in the same fashion?

replies(22): >>18567759 #>>18567975 #>>18568259 #>>18568323 #>>18568762 #>>18568888 #>>18568980 #>>18569170 #>>18569197 #>>18569647 #>>18570201 #>>18570277 #>>18570302 #>>18570546 #>>18570780 #>>18571149 #>>18571876 #>>18571968 #>>18572558 #>>18573347 #>>18576651 #>>18577358 #
village-idiot ◴[] No.18568980[source]
Google’s motto was don’t be evil, they’ve clearly changed their mind.
replies(1): >>18569354 #
api ◴[] No.18569354[source]
Ignore corporate claims such as "don't be evil."

The problem isn't that those claims were lies. I'm sure Google's founders actually intended Google to "not be evil." The problem is that a corporation (or a government, university, church, fraternal organization, you name it) is made up of people. As such things get big they end up being made up of many, many people. Leaders change. Managers change.

When an org gets big some of its people will be assholes because some people are assholes.

Google has been through several CEOs and is a publicly traded company with the latter meaning that it's subject to market pressure and activist investors. It's also a company large enough and relevant enough to be a "national security" interest, making it likely subject to government and intelligence infiltration, pressure, and micromanagement.

replies(1): >>18572530 #
staticautomatic ◴[] No.18572530[source]
So it's OK for them to be evil?
replies(1): >>18573416 #
1. api ◴[] No.18573416[source]
No, I'm saying you shouldn't take the words of corporations the same way you take the words of an individual person. A corporation is not even a singular entity. Corporations can't have values because they're composed of a rotating set of minds that may not all hold those values and there is no way of guaranteeing values will be preserved into the future.