←back to thread

Google Tried to Patent My Work After a Job Interview

(patentpandas.org)
1798 points jerryX | 2 comments | 30 Nov 18 05:25 UTC | HN request time: 0.411s | source
Show context
paul7986 ◴[30 Nov 18 08:45 UTC] No.18567672[source]▶
I met/had a similar experience with Google ATAP in 2013 (was Motorala ATAP then; Google recently bought them) though not for a job interview but to discuss working together to build our tech SpeakerBlast into the Moto X.

They asked if we ever thought about selling our technology to them before the meeting and at the meeting they baited us for how our tech worked saying we'd like to work with you tell us how it works. Once we did they left the room (Dugan's 2nd right hand man at the time and another) & 3 minutes later showed us the door saying the "race is on."

They have since been awarded patents for audio syncing across phones.

Many here will say that's just how Silicon Valley works.... takes advantage and stomps on the little guy innovators & their dreams. That's not professional and I met with many other companies like Samsung who acted with the utmost respect & professionalism towards us. Yet, Google whose motto is "Don't Be Evil," can't act in the same fashion?

replies(22): >>18567759 #>>18567975 #>>18568259 #>>18568323 #>>18568762 #>>18568888 #>>18568980 #>>18569170 #>>18569197 #>>18569647 #>>18570201 #>>18570277 #>>18570302 #>>18570546 #>>18570780 #>>18571149 #>>18571876 #>>18571968 #>>18572558 #>>18573347 #>>18576651 #>>18577358 #
1. headsupftw ◴[30 Nov 18 17:41 UTC] No.18570780[source]▶
“Don't be evil"? Let's see if there's an uproar by Google employees this time. My bet is on "fat chance".
replies(1): >>18575102 #
2. maldeh ◴[01 Dec 18 04:13 UTC] No.18575102[source]▶
Considering all the other corporate strategies Google employees have taken a public stand on lately, I wouldn't be surprised if there were serious fatigue on both ends - on corporate, for dealing with the constant rebellions killing major revenue sources (ex:- project maven's death being the end of any more government contracts); and for employees, who are likely sick of protesting an endless stream of obviously bad stuff while risking career alienation (ex:- dragonfly).

What's not immediately publicly evident is the opportunity cost vis a vis attrition and new hires - how many people have left from disillusionment? How many prospective employees are actively shunning Google directly because of these policies? (While a number might provide explicit feedback to recruiters about their reasons to reject, it's probable a silent majority is silently avoiding all contacts from Google recruiting.) At least personally speaking, I had a vastly more positive view of google around 2012 when I started grad school (more or less my dream company to work for at the time) than what I had when graduating (sufficient to decline any recruiting requests).