←back to thread

1798 points jerryX | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
gammateam ◴[] No.18567313[source]
> More importantly, sharing work publicly keeps the project can alive and inspires others to continue developing!

Which a patent does too, just with a license or 20 years later. It keeps people from reinventing the wheel and gives the disclosure rights even if they didn't have the infrastructure to create or monetize on their own. This isn't one of those nefarious software patents where the whole thing would be obsolete within 5 years, this is LED books, which simply becomes more feasible as transistor sizes shrink and battery technology improves, perfect for a 20 year exclusivity period before falling into the public domain where it can be vastly more practical to create in 2033.

replies(3): >>18567383 #>>18567442 #>>18568096 #
1. AnaniasAnanas ◴[] No.18568096[source]
> It keeps people from reinventing the wheel

Actually it forces people to reinvent the wheel in possibly worse ways.

replies(1): >>18568796 #
2. azeotropic ◴[] No.18568796[source]
Or possibly better. Thinking of the explosion of DNA sequencing technology over the past decade, I'm kind of grateful that people reinvented the wheel about a half-dozen times (Solexa/Illumina, 454, IonTorrent, Solid, PacBio, ONT, etc.)