←back to thread

34 points atoledano | 4 comments | | HN request time: 0.625s | source
1. knaik94 ◴[] No.17955115[source]
If they decide to go through with the change, I hope different languages and program agree on the new term.

I personally believe that lack of clarity is the only reason these kinds of changes should be made.

I assumed that master/slave terminology came from the idea of copying from a master record vinyl, am I missing something?

I just wonder if this will set a precedent of controversy about the most innocuous things, just to make sure it's politically correct.

replies(2): >>17955163 #>>17955751 #
2. ggggtez ◴[] No.17955163[source]
Master slave comes from slavery. Generally the master doles out work for the slaves to do.

Specifically, even if the phrase is based on an earlier technology, what is that technology's terminology based on? There is no other answer but actually slavery at the end.

replies(1): >>17957723 #
3. kevin_b_er ◴[] No.17955751[source]
It is a clbuttic problem. Their politics demands extricating the world "master" from speech because of its supposed connection to slavery. Unfortunately things like "master record vinyl" would lead to "main record vinyl" or "parent record vinyl". This makes it a clbuttic problem. And it isn't that the "pair" must exist. Things that are expressed in the "master record" concept will thus need to be clubuttic'ified.

Why it this? Because it is not motivated by code improvement but by political demands. The clarity of meaning will be lost by these changes for future developers, because of the need to censure the word "master" from speech and writing.

And yes, this sets a precedent that all you need to do find more words on the euphemism treadmill that may be labeled offensive to force their replacement. This will result in further loss of clarity in documentation where clarity can be reduced whenever someone demands that "for diversity reasons" words need to be deleted.

4. nocigar ◴[] No.17957723[source]
Wait until you hear where the word "server" comes from...