←back to thread

668 points wildmusings | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
JorgeGT ◴[] No.13027099[source]
And without an "edited" mark, which means that any comment of any user can be covertly modified by an admin. Very concerning since Reddit comments have provoked even Congress hearings: http://thehill.com/policy/national-security/296680-house-pan...
replies(7): >>13027119 #>>13027125 #>>13027136 #>>13027240 #>>13027734 #>>13028391 #>>13033721 #
dhruval ◴[] No.13027240[source]
He changed a 'F U CEO' (upvoted by 1.6k users) comment to 'F U unpaid reddit moderator', without any indication that the comment was edited.

Very juvenile and unprofessional way of dealing with the situation, really erodes trust in the platform (simply deleting the comment would have been a better response).

Would maybe expect this from the founder of a young fledgling startup, but the 33 year old CEO of a company like Reddit ought to know better.

replies(7): >>13027341 #>>13027345 #>>13027894 #>>13028550 #>>13028557 #>>13031901 #>>13032509 #
kordless ◴[] No.13027341[source]
It's well within his power to change a comment. What's not cool is that he changed it to a lie. If he's the CEO, he's paid.
replies(4): >>13027372 #>>13027414 #>>13027477 #>>13027712 #
bigtunacan ◴[] No.13027477[source]
It's an abuse of power and ethics and is a line that shouldn't be crossed.

It is much more honest and within reason to take steps like deleting posts, suspending or even outright banning users.

replies(2): >>13028195 #>>13037059 #
toomuchtodo ◴[] No.13028195{3}[source]
While an abuse of power, I'm not sure I see the outrage.

It's Reddit. It's an Internet forum run by a private corporation. The users in question abusing spez have zero right to their speech on the platform. You have zero recourse if Reddit edits your comments.

Nuke /r/the_donald, nuke the users and hellban their IPS of those who sent abusive messages, and let's move on. Bask in the irony when I say, "Drain the swamp"

replies(6): >>13028389 #>>13028480 #>>13028622 #>>13028756 #>>13029105 #>>13031043 #
vidarh ◴[] No.13028756{4}[source]
> While an abuse of power, I'm not sure I see the outrage.

This is one of the most bizarre statements I have ever read. You don't understand why people are outraged over abuse of power? Seriously?

> It's Reddit. It's an Internet forum run by a private corporation.

A forum used by users who are pretty much famous for taking a strong dislike to censorship.

> You have zero recourse if Reddit edits your comments.

Zero legal recourse. Plenty of recourse to make a big deal out of it online and damage Reddit's reputation and make others aware when the CEO makes it clear there are additional risks that people didn't expect with using their platform.

replies(1): >>13030089 #
1. oneeyedpigeon ◴[] No.13030089{5}[source]
Abuses of power happen, and are bad, but changing a comment on an internet forum is about as low down on the scale of seriousness as you can get.

The only real problem I can see is that people (at least, here in the UK) have been charged with crimes relating to something they've posted on reddit. Clearly, that's ridiculous if there can be no expectation of proof of authorship.