←back to thread

668 points wildmusings | 4 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
ww520 ◴[] No.13027156[source]
This is pretty bad. That pretty much destroys the credibility of Reddit's commenting system in a single act. No one can look at the integrity of the comments written by others the same any more.
replies(7): >>13027178 #>>13027549 #>>13027655 #>>13027728 #>>13028213 #>>13028308 #>>13028646 #
wfo ◴[] No.13028646[source]
Does it? Really? An admin played a prank on a bunch of insane, out of control conspiracy minded screaming blubbering trolls calling him a pedophile with a dumb silly find/replace rule. God forbid, next forums will start replacing words like 'shit' and 'fuck' with symbols to try and hide the truth of what we /really/ mean from the world.

Who cares? Why is this a big deal? I am so unbelievably unimpressed with the seriousness of this, I feel like there is such an enormous effort to pretend this is "serious business" and "the integrity of reddit" (?) is somehow being compromised. We all knew this could be done. On any forum. Reddit is a silly place. Reddit is a place for people to shitpost memes and puns with throwaway accounts. The Donald is a subreddit that revels in trolling and messing with people, spewing toxic garbage nonstop. They riled up the main admin of reddit so much he did something childish -- a pretty impressive trolling effort. That's the end of this story as far as I can tell.

replies(10): >>13028730 #>>13028903 #>>13029072 #>>13029160 #>>13029303 #>>13029341 #>>13029652 #>>13029731 #>>13032148 #>>13033974 #
Accacin ◴[] No.13029160[source]
Reddit comments and posts have been used in investigations. In the UK a teenager was sentenced for writing some "racist" comment(I'm not saying this is right or wrong, just that it happened).

Just think, the admins have the power to edit your comment as they see fit and you'll have no proof as your comment isn't even marked as edited.

It's a scary thought.

replies(2): >>13029320 #>>13029832 #
joncalhoun ◴[] No.13029832[source]
To clarify, are you suggesting that someone was indicted based purely on a Reddit post?

If so, that in itself is scarier than anything else being discussed here.

To assume Reddit is a unedited source of truth is just insane. Why people felt it was 100% tamper proof is beyond me. I wouldn't even trust public companies like Twitter to not have potential flaws like this.

replies(1): >>13029994 #
1. angry-hacker ◴[] No.13029994[source]
Yes, yes he was. [0]

It's nothing new in UK, they are literally CCTV state now. Don't forget American folks that in most of the countries over here we don't have free speech ;)

And in the light of this news that Reddit CEO edited comments -- it's scary stuff -- for fun or not.

[0] http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/watch-mom...

replies(2): >>13030364 #>>13032278 #
2. aktiur ◴[] No.13030364[source]
Your source says he admitted writing the comments, which is much stronger evidence before a court than the original comment could ever be.
replies(1): >>13031216 #
3. tripzilch ◴[] No.13031216[source]
Do they have plea bargains in the UK?
replies(1): >>13032038 #
4. pjc50 ◴[] No.13032038{3}[source]
No, nor elected prosecutors. There is however a system where if you plead not guilty and are convicted you have to pay towards the court costs: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-32078676