←back to thread

668 points wildmusings | 6 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source | bottom
Show context
qwertyuiop924 ◴[] No.13027184[source]
I was surprised. This was wrong of me.

Reddit (the company) is a wretched hive of scum an villany, where this sort of stuff seems almost regular. Perhaps it wasn't always so: I don't know.

But I can't think of any other forum that would put up with this. If an owner or mod did this on the *chans, the chan in question would be abandoned within the week.

As for HN, dang does as he sees fit, as do the admins: they'll split your thread, redact your post (and if they doesn't, the software will if it gets flagged enough, IIRC), and (or so I heard) even shadowban you of you're bad enough. However, they're mostly right, and not corrupt. And they wouldn't pull crap like this. Blocking a comment that talks about how HN is just a massive circlejerk is one thing: actually altering it to say something else is quite another.

I suppose it might be common on forums run by egotistical gits, but come on, you're heading a company running a large forum/news aggregator. You can do better than an egomaniac with a website.

replies(7): >>13027247 #>>13027279 #>>13027469 #>>13027618 #>>13028540 #>>13028920 #>>13029686 #
VintageCool ◴[] No.13027279[source]
The rest of reddit will accept this because everyone hates /r/the_donald anyway. That subreddit is an abuse of the system already.
replies(2): >>13027298 #>>13027318 #
noobermin ◴[] No.13027318[source]
This brings up memories of when moot messed with /pol/. He turned off the spam prevention scripts and captcha, made every post look like a doubles post, and let an audio recording of cuck porn play on the board page. That was sort of expected from moot though and it was 4chan after all.
replies(1): >>13027344 #
1. qwertyuiop924 ◴[] No.13027344[source]
Well, yes.

but he didn't mess with any of the content of any messages.

If he did, the entire chan would have gone up in flames.

replies(3): >>13027429 #>>13027810 #>>13028286 #
2. tcryvt ◴[] No.13027429[source]
The content was subject to a large amount of wordfilters at the time, which would alter half the posts.
replies(1): >>13027461 #
3. qwertyuiop924 ◴[] No.13027461[source]
...but those were public. It's one thing to have a computer run search and replace on every post in the board. It's quite another to have a mod specifically edit your post, making it look like you said something you didn't.
4. predakanga ◴[] No.13027810[source]
I've been wondering about exactly that - would the perception of this be so negative if spez had inserted javascript to rewrite the messages on that subreddit instead?
replies(1): >>13029441 #
5. ◴[] No.13028286[source]
6. qwertyuiop924 ◴[] No.13029441[source]
No, because that would rewrite everybody's messages. And it would be noticed immediately, so it wouldn't even matter, practically.