←back to thread

How Dropbox Hacks Your Mac

(applehelpwriter.com)
1037 points 8bitben | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.285s | source
Show context
ThomPete ◴[] No.12465792[source]
Dropbox trying to find ways to push the platform is a good thing not a bad thing.

If anything Apple have put so many restrictions on OSX and isn't pushing for much innovation on their side to allow people to build ever more powerful apps.

I understand general security concerns but I don't understand the critique of a company like Dropbox. They are doing the user er service not a disservice by finding a balance between pushing the platform forward while still taking your security concerns into account.

I would personally be more concerned with the fact that Apple haven't done anything fundamental for the osx platform in quite a while which is the exact opposite of what they have done for iOS.

replies(1): >>12467185 #
Gorbzel ◴[] No.12467185[source]
Dropbox is using cached root privs that it now claims it doesn't even need to force itself into full control of your machine, on the back of an accessibility exploit, actively disregards explicit user actions taken to remove it, does this all via SQL injection, and if all of the above doesn't meet the definition of malware, I don't know what does.

All this from a company who recently had one of the largest credential breaches in the history of the Internet

and you think it's okay to "push the platform"?!???!

It's pretty popular these days to say "Delete your account" online. If this wasn't an accidental knee jerk response, please go one step farther and delete any professional involvement you have with software or technology implementation. You don't understand security concerns, nor does your poorly rehashed half-argument about OS X explain why this would be okay on any platform.

A bit emphatic, but if those goes to the greys, so be it. HN is clearly frequented by people with meaningful input in business, product, and engineering decisions. This kind of scapegoat deflection needs to be highlighted as an unacceptable security practice not justified by anything that seems to qualify as entrepreneurial disruption.

replies(2): >>12469042 #>>12470119 #
1. ThomPete ◴[] No.12469042[source]
You can't se the forrest for the trees.

Of course you can claim it's malware, but sometimes malware works FOR the user not against them this is an example of that.

If anything you should put your anger towards Apple who haven't done anything to osx platform for ages.

With regards to security I both understand it and take it very seriously but I have no interest in theoretical debates. In this specific case I have no issue with what Dropbox is doing. I have an issue that Apple haven't found a way to make these things possible without the exploit.

If you feel strongly about it, be my guest delete all your accounts. I see no reason not to trust Dropbox, but hey each to their own.