←back to thread

535 points raddad | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.213s | source
Show context
hobs ◴[] No.11390553[source]
Some additional details from Scott Hanselman:

http://www.hanselman.com/blog/DevelopersCanRunBashShellAndUs...

"This is a real native Bash Linux binary running on Windows itself. It's fast and lightweight and it's the real binaries. This is an genuine Ubuntu image on top of Windows with all the Linux tools I use like awk, sed, grep, vi, etc. It's fast and it's lightweight. The binaries are downloaded by you - using apt-get - just as on Linux, because it is Linux. You can apt-get and download other tools like Ruby, Redis, emacs, and on and on. This is brilliant for developers that use a diverse set of tools like me."

"This runs on 64-bit Windows and doesn't use virtual machines. Where does bash on Windows fit in to your life as a developer?

If you want to run Bash on Windows, you've historically had a few choices.

Cygwin - GNU command line utilities compiled for Win32 with great native Windows integration. But it's not Linux. HyperV and Ubuntu - Run an entire Linux VM (dedicating x gigs of RAM, and x gigs of disk) and then remote into it (RDP, VNC, ssh) Docker is also an option to run a Linux container, under a HyperV VM Running bash on Windows hits in the sweet spot. It behaves like Linux because it executes real Linux binaries. Just hit the Windows Key and type bash. "

replies(11): >>11390574 #>>11390626 #>>11390693 #>>11390705 #>>11390731 #>>11390748 #>>11390890 #>>11391364 #>>11392443 #>>11393237 #>>11402098 #
bitwize ◴[] No.11391364[source]
No. It may be Ubuntu, but it's not Linux. It isn't Linux, anymore than running a Linux userland on NetBSD's Linux "kernel personality" is Linux.
replies(1): >>11391763 #
jhall1468 ◴[] No.11391763[source]
That's being pedantic, honestly. Yes, technically Linux is only the kernel and technically running the Ubuntu run-time on a different kernel isn't running Linux.

However, "Linux" is almost always a reference to GNU tools and the Linux Kernel. It may not be semantically accurate, but take that up with the same people that made literally mean both itself and its opposite.

replies(3): >>11391848 #>>11391927 #>>11392395 #
Joeboy ◴[] No.11392395[source]
Can somebody tell me straightforwardly whether a linux kernel is actually involved in this WinBuntu thing or not?
replies(1): >>11392406 #
1. johnmaguire2013 ◴[] No.11392406[source]
No, it is not.

> A team of sharp developers at Microsoft has been hard at work adapting some Microsoft research technology to basically perform real time translation of Linux syscalls into Windows OS syscalls. Linux geeks can think of it sort of the inverse of "wine" -- Ubuntu binaries running natively in Windows.

http://blog.dustinkirkland.com/2016/03/ubuntu-on-windows.htm...