←back to thread

548 points CharlesW | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
pbw ◴[] No.46155514[source]
There's an HDR war brewing on TikTok and other social apps. A fraction of posts that use HDR are just massively brighter than the rest; the whole video shines like a flashlight. The apps are eventually going to have to detect HDR abuse.
replies(12): >>46155523 #>>46155553 #>>46155558 #>>46155575 #>>46155588 #>>46155591 #>>46155624 #>>46155812 #>>46155958 #>>46156042 #>>46157120 #>>46162670 #
thrdbndndn ◴[] No.46155958[source]
The whole HDR scene still feels like a mess.

I know how bad the support for HDR is on computers (particularly Windows and cheap monitors), so I avoid consuming HDR content on them.

But I just purchased a new iPhone 17 Pro, and I was very surprised at how these HDR videos on social media still look like shit on apps like Instagram.

And even worse, the HDR video I shoot with my iPhone looks like shit even when playing it back on the same phone! After a few trials I had to just turn it off in the Camera app.

replies(3): >>46156194 #>>46156290 #>>46156601 #
1. johncolanduoni ◴[] No.46156290[source]
I wonder if it fundamentally only really makes sense for film, video games, etc. where a person will actually tune the range per scene. Plus, only when played on half decent monitors that don’t just squash BT.2020 so they can say HDR on the brochure.
replies(1): >>46162555 #
2. Dylan16807 ◴[] No.46162555[source]
Even without tuning it shouldn't look worse than squishing to SDR at capture time. There are are significant ecosystem failures that could be fixed.