←back to thread

17 points ChrisArchitect | 9 comments | | HN request time: 0.414s | source | bottom
1. mrtksn ◴[] No.45918550[source]
What is the point of this? Shopping is the primary reason people work, people love shopping. Not only that, people don't know what they what to buy so they learn in by looking at the options for ideas.

Also, the point of buying presents isn't charity or wealth transfer but thinking about the person.

This is a the case of having a solution looking for a problem.

replies(4): >>45918631 #>>45918707 #>>45918816 #>>45921036 #
2. SoftTalker ◴[] No.45918631[source]
Maybe I'm unusual but I hate shopping, especially when it involves wandering randomly through a store looking for something that I haven't identified in advance.

I work to pay the mortgage, pay for food, pay the utilities, and pay for other necessities in life. Shopping as entertainment is way down on the list.

replies(1): >>45918703 #
3. ◴[] No.45918703[source]
4. 1123581321 ◴[] No.45918707[source]
Depends on use cases, I suppose. I knew someone with a lot of nieces and nephews. She would buy them all whatever Amazon said was the hot toy that year for each kid’s age. She would definitely shop with AI. A little crass, sure, but real shopper behavior.
replies(1): >>45918736 #
5. mrtksn ◴[] No.45918736[source]
Interesting but what's the point here? Just give the nephews some money and let them figure out what they want themselves.
replies(1): >>45924169 #
6. thornewolf ◴[] No.45918816[source]
> people love shopping

After going back and forth on this many times, I have concluded: some people love shopping and some people hate shopping. Members of one group generally have trouble understanding the other group also exists.

replies(1): >>45918925 #
7. mrtksn ◴[] No.45918925[source]
I'm member of the group hating to shop for clothes but love shopping most other things.

The reason I hate shopping for clothes is that I don't understand it, I feel overwhelmed and I despise trying clothes on and off. Still, I wouldn't let an AI do my clothes shopping because it doesn't solve my core problem of not knowing what to buy and trying it on.

8. JohnFen ◴[] No.45921036[source]
> Shopping is the primary reason people work, people love shopping.

A whole lot of people really hate shopping.

> Also, the point of buying presents isn't charity or wealth transfer but thinking about the person.

True, which is why I think this sort of tool is antihuman BS. Especially for people who don't like shopping. Someone who I know hates shopping spending time doing it because they want to express how they feel about me makes it an even more meaningful gift. I appreciate a gift someone put effort into more than a gift they didn't, regardless of how much I actually want the thing being given.

9. 1123581321 ◴[] No.45924169{3}[source]
Many people want to give gifts instead of cash, rational or not. The point is, if the use cases exist, it’s not strange for software to address them.