←back to thread

789 points MindBreaker2605 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 1.215s | source
Show context
lm28469 ◴[] No.45897524[source]
But wait they're just about to get AGI why would he leave???
replies(1): >>45897571 #
killerstorm ◴[] No.45897571[source]
LeCun always said that LLMs do not lead to AGI.
replies(2): >>45897613 #>>45897683 #
NitpickLawyer ◴[] No.45897683[source]
He also said other things about LLMs that turned out to be either wrong or easily bypassed with some glue. While I understand where he comes from, and that his stance is pure research-y theory driven, at the end of the day his positions were wrong.

Previously, he very publicly and strongly said:

a) LLMs can't do math. They trick us in poetry but that's subjective. They can't do objective math.

b) they can't plan

c) by the very nature of autoregressive arch, errors compound. So the longer you go in your generation, the higher the error rate. so at long contexts the answers become utter garbage.

All of these were proven wrong, 1-2 years later. "a" at the core (gold at IMO), "b" w/ software glue and "c" with better training regimes.

I'm not interested in the will it won't it debates about AGI, I'm happy with what we have now, and I think these things are good enough now, for several usecases. But it's important to note when people making strong claims get them wrong. Again, I think I get where he's coming from, but the public stances aren't the place to get into the deep research minutia.

That being said, I hope he gets to find whatever it is that he's looking for, and wish him success in his endeavours. Between him, Fei Fei Li and Ilya, something cool has to come out of the small shops. Heck, I'm even rooting for the "let's commoditise lora training" that Mira's startup seems to go for.

replies(3): >>45897933 #>>45898169 #>>45905642 #
1. HarHarVeryFunny ◴[] No.45905642[source]
> So the longer you go in your generation, the higher the error rate. so at long contexts the answers become utter garbage.

Not totally wrong. They can self-correct, but it seems context rot will eventually set in.