←back to thread

Learn Prolog Now

(lpn.swi-prolog.org)
207 points rramadass | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.453s | source
Show context
disambiguation ◴[] No.45902807[source]
I am once again shilling the idea that someone should find a way to glue Prolog and LLMs together for better reasoning agents.

https://news.ycombinator.com/context?id=43948657

Thesis:

1. LLMs are bad at counting the number of r's in strawberry.

2. LLMs are good at writing code that counts letters in a string.

3. LLMs are bad at solving reasoning problems.

4. Prolog is good at solving reasoning problems.

5. ???

6. LLMs are good at writing prolog that solves reasoning problems.

Common replies:

1. The bitter lesson.

2. There are better solvers, ex. Z3.

3. Someone smart must have already tried and ruled it out.

Successful experiments:

1. https://quantumprolog.sgml.net/llm-demo/part1.html

replies(14): >>45903080 #>>45903178 #>>45903192 #>>45903204 #>>45903228 #>>45903263 #>>45903361 #>>45903376 #>>45903458 #>>45903841 #>>45904155 #>>45904166 #>>45904490 #>>45906435 #
1. Avicebron ◴[] No.45903361[source]
@goblinqueen, you around?
replies(1): >>45904054 #
2. lkuty ◴[] No.45904054[source]
@YeGoblynQueenne Dunno if it will ping the person