←back to thread

196 points zmccormick7 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.201s | source
Show context
aliljet ◴[] No.45387614[source]
There's a misunderstanding here broadly. Context could be infinite, but the real bottleneck is understanding intent late in a multi-step operation. A human can effectively discard or disregard prior information as the narrow window of focus moves to a new task, LLMs seem incredibly bad at this.

Having more context, but leaving open an inability to effectively focus on the latest task is the real problem.

replies(10): >>45387639 #>>45387672 #>>45387700 #>>45387992 #>>45388228 #>>45388271 #>>45388664 #>>45388965 #>>45389266 #>>45404093 #
bgirard ◴[] No.45387700[source]
I think that's the real issue. If the LLM spends a lot of context investigating a bad solution and you redirect it, I notice it has trouble ignoring maybe 10K tokens of bad exploration context against my 10 line of 'No, don't do X, explore Y' instead.
replies(6): >>45387838 #>>45387902 #>>45388477 #>>45390299 #>>45390619 #>>45394242 #
dingnuts ◴[] No.45387838[source]
that's because a next token predictor can't "forget" context. That's just not how it works.

You load the thing up with relevant context and pray that it guides the generation path to the part of the model that represents the information you want and pray that the path of tokens through the model outputs what you want

That's why they have a tendency to go ahead and do things you tell them not to do..

also IDK about you but I hate how much praying has become part of the state of the art here. I didn't get into this career to be a fucking tech priest for the machine god. I will never like these models until they are predictable, which means I will never like them.

replies(8): >>45387906 #>>45387974 #>>45387999 #>>45388198 #>>45388215 #>>45388542 #>>45388863 #>>45390695 #
1. spyder ◴[] No.45388863[source]
This is false:

"that's because a next token predictor can't "forget" context. That's just not how it works."

An LSTM is also a next token predictor and literally have a forget gate, and there are many other context compressing models too which remember only the what it thinks is important and forgets the less important, like for example: state-space models or RWKV that work well as LLMs too. But even just a the basic GPT model forgets old context since it's gets truncated if it cannot fit, but that's not really the learned smart forgetting the other models do.