←back to thread

873 points helsinkiandrew | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.623s | source
Show context
sharpshadow ◴[] No.45374509[source]
It would be only just if the Palestinians would get their own state after this.
replies(6): >>45374689 #>>45374724 #>>45374749 #>>45375056 #>>45375089 #>>45375223 #
lupusreal ◴[] No.45374749[source]
Right of return for all Palestinians and their descendants, worldwide.
replies(3): >>45374865 #>>45375623 #>>45376121 #
nailer ◴[] No.45375623[source]
Also for the 850K middle eastern Jews that were kicked out of their countries by arabs?
replies(4): >>45375778 #>>45375825 #>>45375981 #>>45377806 #
1. MSFT_Edging ◴[] No.45375981[source]
On genetic terms, the Palestinians are virtually identical to Semitic Jews.

There's been plenty of slander to try to say they're more arab, but they're essentially close cousins.

Which leads one to believe, perhaps a large amount of the jews in the region simply moved on with the times with the new religion taking hold.

Essentially Israel/Palestine is a fight between cousins, and one side's inlaws who never actually came from the region but converted elsewhere.

So converts vs converts. Do the local converts have a say over the foreign converts?

The idea that land rights can be derived from the bible or spans of 1000s of years is silly, but the ongoing ethnic cleansing of Palestine going back to 1945 is within living memory.

replies(1): >>45378295 #
2. worik ◴[] No.45378295[source]
> On genetic terms...

...race is fiction.

Genetic analysis does not match "racial" classifications

"Race" is a social construct

replies(1): >>45385317 #
3. MSFT_Edging ◴[] No.45385317[source]
I think you missed my point. I'm trying to say a people split, some left, some stayed. The part that left is now doing violence on the part that stayed, claiming ownership of the area.

The goal of the genetic stuff is to point this split out, not delineate races.

Sadly though, this conflict is full of racism. The Gazans are described as "Arabs" and therefore undeserving of the land. If it turns out the Gazans are not Arabs, but also locals to the region, then what does that mean?