←back to thread

170 points mogambo1 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
danparsonson ◴[] No.45292426[source]
I seem to be in a minority but I find user stories or features to be really awkward and unnatural units of work for building software. Sure these things help to define the expected result but they shouldn't directly drive the development process. Imagine building a house that way - you don't build the living room, then the kitchen, then the bathroom etc.; you build floors, walls, the roof... The 'features' or use cases for the building arise out of the combination of different elements that were put into it, and usually right near the end of the build. The same is true for basically anything else that we build or create - if you're making a sculpture, do you finish working on one leg first before you move onto some other part?

Features are vertical slices through the software cake, but the cake is actually made out of horizontal layers. Creating a bunch of servings of cake and then trying to stick them together just results in a fragile mess that's difficult to work with and easy to break.

replies(9): >>45292458 #>>45292564 #>>45292986 #>>45293703 #>>45294397 #>>45296892 #>>45297236 #>>45298940 #>>45307633 #
ath_ray ◴[] No.45298940[source]
"Unit of work" here is the unit for software delivery, and it can be decoupled from how any individual developer plans and executes whatever software they are delivering.

Product requirements are a hypothesis for creating business value, and the only way to test that hypothesis is to actually demonstrate a slice of that value in a way that's legible to all stakeholders involved.

This post is a nice articulation of this: https://blog.nilenso.com/blog/2025/09/17/the-common-sense-un...

replies(2): >>45299303 #>>45299949 #
1. discreteevent ◴[] No.45299303[source]
That post seems to say that the unit of work must be something customer facing. It even qoutes Kent Beck talking about "Weekly delivery of customer-appreciated value".

There is so much great software in the world that wasn't delivered like that and couldn't be delivered like that: Unix, Microsoft Word, Postgres, AutoCAD, The JVM, Google search, Windows, AWS, Robotics, Calculators ....

The software industry seems to have been captured by contractors who used to deliver CRUD apps and now want to make the whole world in their image and likeness.