←back to thread

258 points anigbrowl | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.432s | source
Show context
jleyank ◴[] No.44611189[source]
It's really depressing how the US system seems to have existed "on belief". Once somebody set out to damage or destroy it, away it went. Pretty much without a whimper.

As I recall, the system was set up with 3 branches of government in tension. Obviously, that was naive.

replies(20): >>44611243 #>>44611251 #>>44611274 #>>44611292 #>>44611294 #>>44611300 #>>44611372 #>>44611468 #>>44612747 #>>44612970 #>>44613048 #>>44613100 #>>44613128 #>>44613243 #>>44613469 #>>44613869 #>>44615093 #>>44616024 #>>44616939 #>>44617655 #
lazide ◴[] No.44611251[source]
All systems exist ‘on belief’. And it’s objectively done better than all other known systems it has been running concurrently with (in both longevity and impact).
replies(2): >>44611271 #>>44612924 #
pinkmuffinere ◴[] No.44611271[source]
> it’s objectively done better than all other known systems (in longevity and impact)

I think the US is probably the country which has had the greatest positive impact on the world in the last 150 years (purely a personal opinion). But even so, we’ve only been around like 300 years total. It’s crazy to say that we have _objectively_ had the biggest and longest impact, when there are civilizations that existed for so much longer, and which made massive contributions to the world.

replies(1): >>44611321 #
lazide ◴[] No.44611321[source]
You might want to re-read my comment.

I made no such long term or meta claims.

replies(1): >>44611722 #
pinkmuffinere ◴[] No.44611722[source]
I guess I’m just missing it, I’ve re-read the thread and it still seems like you’re discussing the US? What am I missing? The parent comment you replied to is

> It's really depressing how the US system seems to have existed "on belief". Once somebody set out to damage or destroy it, away it went. Pretty much without a whimper. As I recall, the system was set up with 3 branches of government in tension. Obviously, that was naive.

replies(1): >>44611852 #
lazide ◴[] No.44611852[source]
‘systems it has been running concurrently with’. Aka during the same times.

What other gov’t during the same time period has lasted as long or longer (none that I am aware of), let alone has produced prosperity, etc. to the same extent?

And it isn’t actually gone yet, either.

replies(2): >>44613172 #>>44613573 #
1. worik ◴[] No.44613573[source]
> What other gov’t during the same time period has lasted as long or longer

Yes, very few last 250 years.

USA has had some close calls before, the Civil War was horrific.

Nothing lasts forever, but I would not bet against the USA's system perpetuating itself this time, too