←back to thread

218 points pseudolus | 10 comments | | HN request time: 1.373s | source | bottom
1. itishappy ◴[] No.43572439[source]
Let us know when you convince a few hundred people it's interesting enough to visit!
replies(2): >>43573720 #>>43573789 #
2. renewiltord ◴[] No.43573720[source]
Are you kidding me? I have 8 billion listeners. And a new one born every second.
replies(1): >>43574213 #
3. jacobgkau ◴[] No.43573789[source]
The few hundred people who visited during the 17-month rest are just as silly as someone who'd be convinced to see a random forum poster's millennium rest, that's the kicker.
replies(1): >>43574189 #
4. itishappy ◴[] No.43574189{3}[source]
Maybe if they were visiting just for the music, but perhaps the organ itself is of some interest?
replies(1): >>43574338 #
5. itishappy ◴[] No.43574213{3}[source]
How many of them do you think know your name?
replies(2): >>43574372 #>>43577023 #
6. jacobgkau ◴[] No.43574338{4}[source]
Sure, if you want to make it about the engineering accomplishment rather than the music itself. Somewhat to your point, I guess I have more respect for Rainer Neugebauer and the team actually attempting to put this performance on than for John Cage simply writing it down vaguely.
replies(1): >>43574739 #
7. AlexandrB ◴[] No.43574372{4}[source]
So art is all about the identity of the author?
replies(1): >>43574683 #
8. itishappy ◴[] No.43574683{5}[source]
I'd say it's about connecting with the consumer. The connection doesn't need to extend to the author, but it should probably extend to the art itself.

I'll rephrase my question: How many of those 8 billion people care about and/or are aware of Rene's art?

9. itishappy ◴[] No.43574739{5}[source]
Totally agree. I think Cage's work is vaguely interesting in an abstract sorta way, but the actually interesting part of this piece is the organ itself. I think they're both art, but I personally value the latter more.
10. renewiltord ◴[] No.43577023{4}[source]
"A society grows great when old men plant trees in whose bark their name is not written" - ancient Chinese proverb.