Most active commenters

    ←back to thread

    2127 points bakugo | 15 comments | | HN request time: 1.392s | source | bottom
    1. jonas21 ◴[] No.43163279[source]
    > Why would my phone number be any of their business?

    Preventing abuse? It's much harder to create a throwaway phone number than a throwaway email address.

    > OpenAI does the logical thing. Let's me enter my credit card and I'm good to go. I will stay with them.

    You'd rather hand over your credit card than your phone number? I think most people would see it the other way around.

    replies(3): >>43163297 #>>43163325 #>>43163374 #
    2. I_am_tiberius ◴[] No.43163280[source]
    That's the reason I've not yet signed up. After trying to use some anonymous sms service (which failed), I'm still not having an account:).
    replies(1): >>43163336 #
    3. whalesalad ◴[] No.43163295[source]
    https://hushed.com/ or specifically this offer https://promo.hushed.com/lp/lifetime-3 which will get you a lifetime number for $25
    4. rcstank ◴[] No.43163297[source]
    Credit card is easily changed. Phone number is much more difficult.
    replies(2): >>43163314 #>>43163388 #
    5. alsodumb ◴[] No.43163299[source]
    Honestly I don't think Anthropic cares about you moving over to them - it's pretty evident that they already have more demand than they can handle.

    I've always had better experience with Claude in day-to-day coding and text writing, and looking at public forums that largely seems to be the case.

    6. whywhywhywhy ◴[] No.43163314{3}[source]
    Not difficult at all for anyone actually wanting to abuse it
    replies(1): >>43163418 #
    7. brendoelfrendo ◴[] No.43163325[source]
    > You'd rather hand over your credit card than your phone number?

    You know, that was my first reaction, too. But really, my phone number is much more integral to my identity. I can cancel or change a credit card number pretty trivially and then it's useless to you.

    8. pushcx ◴[] No.43163336[source]
    They block numbers from any provider considered to be voip.
    9. 42lux ◴[] No.43163345[source]
    Not for the api.
    10. rustc ◴[] No.43163368[source]
    > OpenAI does the logical thing. Let's me enter my credit card and I'm good to go. I will stay with them.

    When did you make your account? I could have sworn I had to verify with my phone number before payment.

    11. pseudocomposer ◴[] No.43163374[source]
    Many credit card companies make it easy to generate one-off card numbers/“virtual cards” you can use to subscribe to services that are hard to cancel or otherwise questionable (so you can cancel just the card you used for that company).
    12. ◴[] No.43163376[source]
    13. crazygringo ◴[] No.43163388{3}[source]
    You credit card is also easily charged.

    Your phone number isn't.

    What is a company going to do with your phone number that you're worried about...?

    14. behnamoh ◴[] No.43163418{4}[source]
    You shouldn't have to want to abuse something for it to be inappropriate to be asked.
    replies(1): >>43193775 #
    15. whywhywhywhy ◴[] No.43193775{5}[source]
    I agree just debunking the excuse that's always wheeled out for this overreach.