←back to thread

CDC data are disappearing

(www.theatlantic.com)
749 points doener | 6 comments | | HN request time: 1.03s | source | bottom
Show context
paulyy_y ◴[] No.42898268[source]
What's more depressing is this was completely predictable, totally avoidable, but half the country welcomed this wave of oppression with open arms.
replies(7): >>42898405 #>>42898480 #>>42898632 #>>42898681 #>>42898826 #>>42899048 #>>42899112 #
diggan ◴[] No.42898405[source]
> but half the country welcomed this wave of oppression with open arms.

And the other half? They seem to welcome this as well, but with crossed arms. Where are the protests? Seems most people end up writing upset messages on Twitter/Bluesky, but also seems there are no grassroots movements to actually protest the borderline coup that is happening?

replies(9): >>42898442 #>>42898465 #>>42898473 #>>42898500 #>>42898563 #>>42898604 #>>42899196 #>>42903681 #>>42905726 #
CalRobert ◴[] No.42898442[source]
Protest doesn't do anything. I marched plenty and it accomplished nothing except letting like-minded people blow off a bit of steam and feel like something we did mattered. If anything it was just a distraction.
replies(3): >>42898513 #>>42898887 #>>42899020 #
diggan ◴[] No.42898887[source]
> Protest doesn't do anything.

Most rights that workers have today have been earned through protesting (and sometimes the bloody consequence of protesting while the state is resisting wanted changes). Protests only "doesn't do anything" when you don't do it enough or give up. Maybe I'm too European to understand, but the "pacifist" approach of the US working class seems to not be working out great.

replies(2): >>42898989 #>>42899008 #
Dalewyn ◴[] No.42899008[source]
It seems like you're missing something pretty basic here, so here it goes:

Government workers going on strike means they're doing what we want them to do, which is nothing. As a Trump voter, I want these federal government workers to stop working so the astronomical waste of our time/money and disturbing of peace stops.

The best work the US government does is when it's doing nothing, because it's hardly working properly unless it's forced to (ICE is an example of government actually working again).

Whether the workers resign, strike/protest, or get back to work implementing MAGA policies in the office, we win.

replies(2): >>42899083 #>>42899718 #
Spooky23 ◴[] No.42899083[source]
The good news is that as a Trump voter who is a MAGA believer, you’ve established that you’re ignorant and open to emotional manipulation. You’re the political equivalent of the old lady who talks to the scammers.

So when your glorious day comes, and your State asserts their rights and levies your bank account to pay for your parents medical bills as your filial responsibility, (or whatever your personal tragedy ends up being) you’ll have the feels, and will flip to the next cult of personality.

replies(2): >>42899206 #>>42899289 #
1. antman ◴[] No.42899403[source]
So you have no reality filter to alert you on the condoms claim?
replies(1): >>42899569 #
2. ◴[] No.42899686[source]
3. nullocator ◴[] No.42899940[source]
I don't think there is any evidence to backup those claims (assuming you're talking about "$50 million sent to Gaza for condoms").

I don't believe you are arguing in good faith otherwise I'd think you'd also be upset about the millions of tax dollars spent so that one man can golf? Which there are actual receipts for [1].

[1] https://www.npr.org/2019/02/05/691684859/government-watchdog...

4. galangalalgol ◴[] No.42900609{3}[source]
I like minimal government too. It has a few necessary roles, and foreign aid isn't one. Why are we recognizing that with Ukraine, and Mozambique but not Israel? Keeping the free market working by trust-bustingbis one too. I welcome a true house cleaning, but we are just trading regulatory capture for unregulated corruption. You wanted the land of do as you please, but got the land of do as they please. This is just an authoritarian power grab under the guise of renewal. I could be wrong, but as others have said, the proof will be in how the response to legal challenges to the house cleaning go. If they are ignored or rubber stamped by the scotus no matter how obviously they violate the law, then we know I am right. If some of the move fast and break things gets stopped by the scotus, or the admin backs down when things get challenged as illegal, then maybe this is exactly what we needed. I am not hopeful.

Edit: I think I was being disingenuous about foreign aid, sometimes foreign aid can be necessary to protect the well-being of US citizens. Stopping pandemics early or preventing them. Standing by a treaty so people know our word is good. Maintaining access to a resource our economy depends on etc. I just find it telling that the only foreign aid that was exempted was to Israel.

5. vharuck ◴[] No.42900773{3}[source]
In 2024, US companies exported $137.8 million to Mozambique, and imported $201.7 million from that country[0]. If that country were crippled by a healthcare crisis, that's less business for companies in the US and other countries that also deal with the US. Supply chains, interconnectedness, and all that. It also helps to have allies across the world. Allies who have close ties with our health agencies, and might tell us about potential outbreaks of infectious diseases. Or terrorist organizations. Also, have you noticed terrorists mostly come from countries with shattered economies and weak governments? Not to mention that STDs are contagious and don't stay home when the host travels internationally.

International politics is complicated. Anyone who shows you a single line item without context is deceiving you. Especially if the number is related to sex and a disease associated with promiscuity. That's a red flag. Their stats may be true, but their stated goal isn't.

[0]: https://www.census.gov/foreign-trade/balance/c7870.html

6. Spooky23 ◴[] No.42901217[source]
Cool. The Russians would call you “polezniye duraki”.

Hopefully someday you’ll ask yourself why you paid heed to some misinformation nonsense about African condoms and got upset about it.

In the meantime, try to stay away from power tools.