←back to thread

The man who killed Google Search?

(www.wheresyoured.at)
1884 points elorant | 9 comments | | HN request time: 0.217s | source | bottom
Show context
siliconc0w ◴[] No.40136456[source]
Hard to place the blame on a single person, though I do think a "management consultant wearing an engineer costume" captures Google's engineering leadership these days
replies(1): >>40137059 #
1. A_D_E_P_T ◴[] No.40137059[source]
Yeah. But what do you expect when the boss comes from McKinsey? Not only does the place teach a particular skillset, it also selects for very peculiar employees. It would be downright weird if an ex-McKinsey employee were anything like a decent engineer.
replies(2): >>40138085 #>>40138102 #
2. throwaway11460 ◴[] No.40138085[source]
McKinsey has absolutely stellar engineers and engineering leadership in its internal software teams, it's a gift and joy to work with them. Not sure about the consulting side though.
3. wepple ◴[] No.40138102[source]
Are there known examples of ex-McKinsey employees that are generally considered a force for good in general?
replies(5): >>40138582 #>>40139127 #>>40139334 #>>40139790 #>>40140431 #
4. notzane ◴[] No.40138582[source]
Jørgen Vig Knudstorp saved Lego
5. Nathanael_M ◴[] No.40139127[source]
Peter Attia's book on longevity is really wonderful, as is his public discourse and research.
6. karaterobot ◴[] No.40139334[source]
The best manager I ever had was an ex-McKinsey consultant. Extremely empathetic, super competent, good dude. I have not worked with him for years but still text him for advice, and he delivers. I suppose that there are people who left McKinsey because they thought they could make more money elsewhere, and people who left McKinsey because they realized they made a huge mistake working there.
7. sundalia ◴[] No.40139790[source]
Jeremy Howard comes to mind. The sheer good that fast.ai brought as free quality educational material feels enough for "good in general" :)
8. snowwrestler ◴[] No.40140431[source]
Tom Peters’ work on management excellence is generally well-regarded and he started it at McKinsey.

He’s also more recently spoken pretty aggressively about how he thinks McKinsey has lost their way as a business and become a negative force.

replies(1): >>40206105 #
9. eschaton ◴[] No.40206105{3}[source]
Not that well-regarded any more since his fabrications came to light.