←back to thread

1061 points danso | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.417s | source
Show context
darkerside ◴[] No.23349412[source]
As President, or any public figure, you are responsible not only for the intention of your words, but also every feasible interpretation of your words, as well as the impacts of your words, regardless of intention.

I say this not to imply that Trump didn't know that this statement could be taken in multiple ways, but to remind people that even if it can it doesn't matter. It's tragic this has happened, and also tragic to have a leader who reacts to the situation in this way, and that a large swath of the country applauds him for it.

Vague and menacing threats are much more thuggish behavior than emotional reaction to the killing of an unarmed civilian.

As for what Twitter is doing, I'm curious whether they follow this path to it's logical conclusion, which is, eventually Trump being banned from Twitter. He's a huge driver of traffic for them, but perhaps they're thinking about life after Trump at this point, months away from the election.

replies(3): >>23349430 #>>23349449 #>>23349483 #
SpicyLemonZest ◴[] No.23349430[source]
Vague and menacing threats are admittedly thuggish behavior, but I think it's hard to argue that it's more thuggish than burning down a police station.
replies(4): >>23349512 #>>23349652 #>>23352992 #>>23359819 #
AshleyGrant ◴[] No.23349652[source]
Well of course it isn't "more thuggish." The use of "thug" was done on purpose. It is a known racist dog whistle. Trump's racist followers know exactly what he means when he says "These THUGS are..." They replace that with the n word. It's just as a society we don't allow them to say the n word any more, so they've replaced it with a myriad of dog whistles.

What I'm saying is that, in their minds, every single person in that mob is a "thug," and everything they're doing is (in your words) "thuggish."

But the mob of white folks in Charlottesville? Nothing thuggish there. That's just white folks protesting against being oppressed by minorities.

replies(2): >>23349710 #>>23350040 #
SpicyLemonZest ◴[] No.23349710[source]
I would call any group of people who burns down a police station, or breaks into a Target and starts stealing stuff, thuggish. The mob of white folks in Charlottesville did not, as far as I know, do these things.
replies(1): >>23350297 #
AshleyGrant ◴[] No.23350297[source]
Yeah, they only murdered a black person. That's not nearly as bad as burning a building.

/s for those who can't see that I'm responding to someone who has been trolling this thread hard

replies(2): >>23350495 #>>23359840 #
1. dang ◴[] No.23359555[source]
You broke the site guidelines badly. We ban accounts that do that. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here.