←back to thread

1061 points danso | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.632s | source
Show context
midasz ◴[] No.23347216[source]
Wow. This man needs a lesson on how to deescalate a situation properly. Will this heavy handed approach really make people less angry? I doubt it..
replies(6): >>23347234 #>>23347262 #>>23347368 #>>23347531 #>>23347663 #>>23353690 #
101404 ◴[] No.23347368[source]
The National Guard would go to stop violence, wouldn't it?

Pretty interesting how people even here try to invert the situation for political reasons.

replies(3): >>23347381 #>>23347393 #>>23351425 #
midasz ◴[] No.23347381[source]
You tell me, he quite literally says the military is with him and ready to shoot when people start looting.

Please tell me how I am inverting the situation? Or should I use your translation book to make sense of his tweets?

replies(2): >>23347431 #>>23347434 #
roenxi ◴[] No.23347434[source]
> You tell me, he quite literally says the military is with him and ready to shoot when people start looting.

He didn't literally say that. The National Guard would be acting in a role very similar to the police when there is rioting.

replies(3): >>23347484 #>>23347523 #>>23351029 #
midasz ◴[] No.23347484[source]
> Just spoke to Governor Tim Walz and told him that the Military is with him all the way. Any difficulty and we will assume control but, when the looting starts, the shooting starts. Thank you!
replies(1): >>23347601 #
blackflame7000 ◴[] No.23347601[source]
And that's bad because...? We can't succumb to lawlessness if people don't respect the law and expect no penalties. If they did the same thing at Area51 and were shot, would you say it's the fault of the guard who swore to protect their post just as the National Guard does? Is the value of civility not greater than a single life?
replies(2): >>23347766 #>>23351014 #
dannyw ◴[] No.23347766[source]
Should people be shot for looting?

Is looting a capital crime?

replies(2): >>23348238 #>>23351333 #
1. dannyw ◴[] No.23349084[source]
I don't follow the logic that a crime against property should become a capital crime just because it is down by a large(unorganised) group of people. Furthermore, the constitution guarantees a fair right to a jury trial, no matter how egregious, and police or the national guard shooting to kill looters goes against that.

Should drug smugglers be shot too? They are also going against societal order.

replies(1): >>23349663 #
2. username90 ◴[] No.23349663[source]
A rebellion is different, if you have to deploy the military because people have overpowered the police then it is no longer just a normal crime scene. Normally people would just disperse when that happens, but if they tried to attack the military in the same way they attack the police then what would you expect?
3. OldHand2018 ◴[] No.23349708[source]
A protest against a citizen who had his life taken without due process of law is getting out of hand.

Doing the same on a much larger scale is not going to improve any situation whatsoever. It will be the exact opposite of a deterrent to others.