Most active commenters

    ←back to thread

    350 points tepidandroid | 12 comments | | HN request time: 0.437s | source | bottom
    Show context
    gcatalfamo ◴[] No.21023650[source]
    This is how you create terrorists. What do you think the children and friends feelings towards the US will be from now on? People get radicalized for much less than that.
    replies(12): >>21023867 #>>21023882 #>>21024090 #>>21024098 #>>21024108 #>>21024127 #>>21024148 #>>21024258 #>>21024722 #>>21025214 #>>21025358 #>>21025914 #
    alpb ◴[] No.21024258[source]
    > This is how you create terrorists.

    Um no, you are wrong.

    _What USA does_ is terrorism. When you drop bombs on people out of nowhere, that's called terrorism. Sorry if you're an American but you've got some learning to do about the biggest terrorist organization in the world before calling others a terrorist. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vRbnPA3fd5U

    replies(8): >>21024327 #>>21024343 #>>21024354 #>>21024521 #>>21024526 #>>21024607 #>>21024691 #>>21024948 #
    1. whiddershins ◴[] No.21024607[source]
    Just stop. Absolutely stop equating these things.

    The world as we know it, the progress in art, science, and humanities. The cures for polio, infant mortality and poverty dropping.

    The website you are currently using to spread poison.

    Those are all “_What USA does_”

    Cut it out with this evil language.

    replies(6): >>21024656 #>>21024663 #>>21024665 #>>21024668 #>>21024748 #>>21024907 #
    2. TeMPOraL ◴[] No.21024656[source]
    Good you mention cures for polio. The US does both cures for polio and ensuring polio exists and spreads, by virtue of CIA pretending to be agents of vaccination charities, which killed polio eradication efforts in some places.

    Point being, the US does a lot of things. Some good, some bad. You don't get to trade the good things for the bad things. There could be progress in art, science and humanities without indiscriminate drone bombings of innocent civilians worldwide.

    3. soVeryTired ◴[] No.21024663[source]
    I mean - the US can simultaneously do very good things and very bad things.
    4. icebraining ◴[] No.21024665[source]
    I don't see how that prevents an organization from doing terrorist actions. In fact, it's fairly common, for example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hezbollah_social_services
    5. brosinante ◴[] No.21024668[source]
    How dare people criticize the U.S. They certainly created art, science and the humanities, not to mention put them in books to civilize all those shithole countries?

    I was not aware that curing polio is a global absolution of sins.

    6. alpb ◴[] No.21024748[source]
    I think the downvotes you got speak for itself. I am not even gonna bother answering.

    Also USA has some of the highest infant mortality and poverty rates in the western world.

    replies(1): >>21025518 #
    7. lm28469 ◴[] No.21024907[source]
    I mean, the US are not even 250 years old and built by immigrants. The rest of the world didn't wait for them for science, medicine, art and philosophy. From a social standpoint they're still 20-30 years behind most EU countries for example.

    I think most americans fail to recognise how much propaganda they're constantly fed about how great the US are. From the outside it almost looks like a parody, especially since Trump is in the office. Example: https://www.vox.com/2014/6/16/5814270/the-successful-70-year...

    8. jacobush ◴[] No.21025887{3}[source]
    What prevented World War 3 so far was Mutually Assured Desctruction. "M.A.D." is beginning to look a bit long in the tooth, but it's clinging on to life yet.
    9. mad_tortoise ◴[] No.21025954{3}[source]
    Man stop drinking the kool-aid. You're lapping up your countries propoganda left, right and center. Apparently according to you, art, science and the humanities wouldn't exist if not for the USA? Get out of here, this is hackernews not 4chan.
    replies(1): >>21026075 #
    10. saiya-jin ◴[] No.21026029{3}[source]
    > It’s so fashionable to hate America, that must make it true.

    Let's be honest here, US is trying hard for last 15 years to be the most hated country anywhere, ever.

    Millions of innocent civilians killed based on outright lies by US president in Iraq 2nd war (they were so glaringly obvious on UN meeting when GWB presented them that Germany and France outright rejected joining. UK couldn't care less). The consequences are felt across half of Asia and whole Europe till these days. Please tell me, what justice system in US does to a person who kills innocents without any reason? Nothing good. And if you kill millions? Good pension and CIA protection for rest of your life apparently. Plus Afghanistan, yet another battlefield where mighty US army is losing a battle with guys with AKs.

    Another topic is online privacy, US could have been champion of freedom, and initially it was, but we had Snowden and stuff ain't better since then. That's plain amoral. Currently US can't claim much moral superiority over China for outsiders, like it or not.

    I ain't even touching the topic of current US president because that would be for a separate thread.

    To like US and its role in current politics these days requires super strong tint on ones pink glasses. Most of the world is kind of fed up and just wants to be left alone, not invaded for US version of 'freedom', oil, strategic place or whatever.

    This is real world out there, where 95% of the mankind lives.

    11. whiddershins ◴[] No.21026075{4}[source]
    It’s hard to make art when your country is being torn to shreds by war.

    How much art was coming out of East Germany under the Soviet Union?

    What other nation is deterring constant military expansion of China and Russia?

    How many nations are confronting IS?

    You are either naive or destructive.

    replies(1): >>21026267 #
    12. pnako ◴[] No.21026267{5}[source]
    IS was created after the US destroyed Iraq, based on false evidence (just like America invaded Afghanistan based on false reasons). The damage is done, but why persist? What do you expect to happen exactly?

    In fact Russia consolidated its influence and alliances in the middle east just by exploiting American mistakes there.

    Just leave. It would be a hugely popular move everywhere: among the left, the right, veterans, other countries, etc. So why not do it?